As Bitcoin prices repeatedly fluctuate around $76,000 and are now approaching the $70,000 mark, the longstanding debate between gold advocate Peter Schiff and Bitcoin steadfast supporter Michael Saylor has reignited. Schiff directly criticizes Strategy’s Bitcoin holdings, which amount to approximately $54 billion, claiming they “hardly create any real value,” and mocks that its current price has nearly reached the company’s average cost basis, implying that this high-stakes gamble is on the verge of breaking even or incurring losses.
Schiff states that, based on the current price, Strategy has an unrealized loss of about 3%, and warns that risks could further increase over the next five years. He emphasizes that Bitcoin’s history is still too short to be considered a reliable long-term store of value. In his view, the company’s high concentration of assets in a single cryptocurrency inherently carries systemic risks.
Meanwhile, Saylor’s camp argues that this assessment overlooks the impact of macroeconomic conditions and liquidity cycles. Some community members point out that Strategy’s buying pace spans multiple market phases, and short-term price declines are more likely due to macro tightening and reduced risk appetite rather than a failure of Bitcoin’s fundamentals. The contraction of dollar liquidity and weakness in the US stock market have forced investors to reprice all high-volatility assets.
In terms of market performance, Strategy recently disclosed an unrealized paper loss exceeding $900 million, with MSTR’s stock price falling back to around $133, down more than 6% for the day. Bitcoin also weakened slightly during the same period, further fueling concerns about the company’s financial stability. Nevertheless, Strategy remains the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin globally, with over 710,000 coins, a scale that still holds symbolic significance within the institutional sector.
This “gold versus Bitcoin” value debate is no longer just a clash of individual opinions but a long-term contest between two asset logics. Whether short-term fluctuations will shake Strategy’s confidence remains uncertain, but as the cost basis and market price continue to narrow, risk management and capital structure issues are being pushed into sharper focus.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
BTC fell below 77000 USDT
Gate News bot message, Gate quotes show that BTC fell below 77000 USDT, trading at 76961.6 USDT.
CryptoRadar12m ago
NYSE Welcomes Morgan Stanley’s MSBT Launch as First Spot Bitcoin ETF Issued by a Major US Bank
Bank-backed bitcoin ETFs are accelerating institutional adoption and strengthening market credibility. The NYSE marked a new milestone as Morgan Stanley Investment Management rang the closing bell and celebrated the launch of MSBT, which the NYSE described as the first spot bitcoin ETF by a major
Coinpedia3h ago
BTC falls 0.49% in 15 minutes: fragile long leverage and active sell-off pressure resonate to weigh on the short term
From 18:00 to 18:15 (UTC) on 2026-04-17, the BTC price fluctuated and trended downward within the 77097.4 to 77573.2 USDT range. Over these 15 minutes, the return rate recorded -0.49%, and the amplitude reached 0.61%. During this period, market trading was active; short-term volatility was amplified, and trading attention increased significantly. The main driver behind this abnormal move is that the overall leverage structure is bearish and long positions are fragile. At present, the BTC perpetual contract funding rate has remained negative for 11 consecutive days, indicating that the bears have the upper hand in the market. In addition, futures open interest (OI) is about 628.3 billion USDT, which is at a historical high. During the anomaly window, trading volume increased noticeably. On-chain data shows large amounts of BTC flowing from long-term holder addresses to exchanges, suggesting that active sell orders may have triggered longs to passively reduce positions, amplifying downward price pressure. Moreover, institutional positioning enthusiasm in the mainstream contract market has cooled off; liquidity boundaries have tightened, causing large-trade activity to have an amplified effect on market volatility. In the options market, implied volatility rose to 39.81%, increasing demand for downside protection and reflecting a defensive posture among market participants. Macro-environment volatility and some capital flowing into safe-haven assets, together with the recent regulatory uncertainty-related historical events, reinforced the move, pushing overall market risk appetite lower. Current BTC leverage risks still remain. If, in the future, there are concentrated sell-offs, volatility may be further amplified. It is recommended to continue monitoring sustained high OI levels, the persistence of negative funding rates, and on-chain transfers of large amounts of funds, and to stay alert for whale behavior and any disruptions to market sentiment caused by macro-policy developments. For subsequent price action, please watch key support levels, institutional and whale on-chain moves, and relevant global market news, and guard against short-term risks.
GateNews5h ago
Bitcoin Liquidations Hit $815M as BTC Surges Above $78K Amid Iran Strait Opening
Over $815 million in leveraged cryptocurrency positions were liquidated recently, mainly due to short positions against Bitcoin. Markets improved as Iran reopened the Strait of Hormuz and Trump hinted at a deal with Iran, boosting Bitcoin prices significantly.
GateNews5h ago
Cardano Founder Hoskinson Warns BIP-361 Could Freeze 1.7M Bitcoin
Charles Hoskinson warned that Bitcoin's BIP-361 upgrade, meant to address quantum threats, is wrongly classified as a soft fork. It could freeze 1.7 million BTC, including 1 million from Satoshi Nakamoto, as early coin owners can't prove ownership.
GateNews6h ago
