Bitcoin's Quantum Defense Plan BIP-361 Draws Criticism Over 1.7M BTC Recovery Gap

BTC0,64%

Gate News message, April 17 — Bitcoin developers are advancing BIP-361, a contingency plan to counter quantum computing threats by gradually phasing out vulnerable address types and requiring users to migrate funds into quantum-resistant formats. The upgrade could safeguard over 7 million Bitcoin—approximately 34% of total supply—valued at roughly $536 billion by freezing coins that fail to migrate within set deadlines.

Cardano founder Charles Hoskinson has raised significant concerns about the proposal’s scope and execution. He argues that approximately 1.7 million BTC, including roughly 1 million linked to early mining activity, cannot meet the recovery requirements under BIP-361. These coins were generated using earlier cryptographic methods that lack seed phrases, preventing them from producing the proofs required by the proposed recovery mechanism, which would result in their permanent freezing if the upgrade were enacted in its current form.

Hoskinson has further criticized how BIP-361 is presented, contending that its actual impact would align more closely with a hard fork—a type of change historically resisted within Bitcoin’s development culture—rather than the soft fork classification being promoted. The debate underscores ongoing challenges in reaching consensus on how Bitcoin should address emerging technological risks and major protocol changes.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to Disclaimer.

Related Articles

22,000 BTC Options and 100,000 ETH Options Expire Today; BTC Max Pain at $72,000

On April 17, 22,000 BTC options are expiring with a 1.05 Put/Call ratio and a $72,000 maximum pain point, totaling $1.65 billion. Additionally, 100,000 ETH options are expiring with a 0.95 Put/Call ratio and a $2,250 maximum pain point, valued at $460 million.

GateNews12m ago

Bitcoin Composite Market Index (BCMI) Approaches High-Conviction Support Zone, Signals Value Accumulation Phase

Bitcoin's Composite Market Index is testing a crucial pivot level, indicating BTC is historically undervalued. Key metrics like MVRV and NUPL show reset investor sentiment, while a downtrend in the 90-day SMA suggests ongoing selling pressure.

GateNews57m ago

Listed Bitcoin Miners Sold Over 32,000 BTC in Q1 2026, Exceeding Full-Year 2025 Total

Bitcoin miners sold over 32,000 BTC in Q1 2026, exceeding 2025's total sales. Key players include MARA, Riot, and Core Scientific. Miner profitability is declining as hash prices fall below breakeven, with reserves down from 1.86 million to 1.80 million BTC.

GateNews1h ago

European Companies Build Bitcoin Treasury Strategy Diverging from MicroStrategy Model

European companies are adopting Bitcoin treasury strategies that align with local regulations, in contrast to the U.S. debt-driven model. Key players like Germany's Bitcoin Group SE and France's Capital B focus on conservative positions, facing unique market constraints.

GateNews2h ago

Underlying asset structure, yield mechanics, and the 21Shares statement

21Shares CEO Duncan Moir said in a statement: “Since our founding, we have been focused on providing a convenient digital-asset investment pathway. With this product, we extend that expertise into equity-linked investment areas tied to the Bitcoin ecosystem.” Moir also said the product “combines high yield potential with a familiar exchange-traded structure,” targeting both institutional and retail investors.

SuperCryptoWahaha666665h ago
Comment
0/400
No comments