The death of Iran’s leader sparks controversy in prediction markets; Kalshi refunds $2.2 million, with the CEO claiming they refused “death arbitrage.” Before the airstrike, U.S. lawmakers demanded strict scrutiny of contracts related to war and assassination predictions, with a deadline to respond by March 9.
Kalshi’s “Khamenei Resignation” Prediction Contract Sparks Debate
Following the joint U.S. and Israeli airstrikes that resulted in the death of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour stated that their platform’s trading volume exceeded $50 million on contracts related to the event. He emphasized that their goal was to prevent investors from profiting from the death.
The contract was titled: “Will Khamenei step down as Iran’s Supreme Leader?” with rules stating that if Khamenei dies, settlement would be based on the last trading price before death. When news of Khamenei’s death broke, a surge of funds flooded into the contract, and Kalshi suspended trading due to settlement chaos.
Kalshi later admitted that the settlement terms contained ambiguous language and ultimately decided to refund users’ net losses. Sources told Bloomberg that this move cost the platform about $2.2 million.
Kalshi’s Promotion and Settlement Standards Under Fire
After Kalshi processed refunds, criticism emerged within the community, mainly because Kalshi had promoted this contract at the time of the event. Last Saturday morning, news of Khamenei’s death began circulating, Kalshi posted on X: “Breaking: The probability of Khamenei no longer serving as Iran’s Supreme Leader has surged to 68%,” which Mansour also retweeted.
Image source: X
Former SEC Chief of Staff Amanda Fischer criticized this, saying Kalshi’s actions were akin to providing a marketplace for assassination proxies.
Users also criticized Kalshi’s settlement standards, pointing out that when Jimmy Carter passed away, the platform settled his contract as “no,” accusing the platform of only applying special terms when losing money.
Dennis Kelleher, CEO of Better Markets, stated that Kalshi’s actions reveal an attempt to balance expanding trading volume with avoiding clear laws banning assassination-related bets.
Prediction Markets Cross the Line, U.S. Lawmakers Call for Investigation
Prediction markets are often seen as “anything can be traded,” but this incident highlights their limits. Before the U.S.-Israel airstrikes on Iran, California Democratic Senator Adam Schiff sent a letter to CFTC Chair Michael Selig demanding strict regulation of contracts related to war and assassination, with a response deadline of March 9.
Connecticut Democratic Senator Chris Murphy also announced he is drafting legislation to ban such market contracts to prevent insider trading and manipulation based on known outcomes. The Kalshi settlement controversy proves that such betting markets should not exist.
Polymarket’s Wordplay Sparks Controversy
Compared to Kalshi, Polymarket still hosts 187 Iran-related markets. One of these predicts whether the U.S. will forcibly remove Khamenei before March 31. Polymarket ultimately settled this contract as “no,” reasoning that the U.S. only contributed or assisted in the killing, which sparked strong dissatisfaction among some commentators and calls for dispute resolution.
Because Polymarket relies on blockchain-based decentralized settlement mechanisms, the fairness of contract judgments remains under scrutiny.
On-chain data shows that, hours before the airstrike, six anonymous wallets collectively bet on “U.S. attacking Iran before February 28,” ultimately earning about $1.2 million. These wallets were almost all newly created accounts in February, with funds transferred within 24 hours before the event. Such suspicious trading patterns have raised concerns about military secrets leaking and potential on-chain insider arbitrage.
Related report:
Pre-airstrike prediction? Polymarket traders bet on US-Iran war, earning $1.2 million, sparking controversy
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Polymarket website redesign! Probability curves and trading volume become the new headlines, redefining news media
Polymarket has recently undergone a redesign, introducing carousel and Breaking News features that turn capital flow into real-time news, challenging traditional media. The new homepage displays trending events and treats data fluctuations as news, emphasizing the value of real-time predictions. This redesign transforms Polymarket from a betting platform into a real-time news source, solving information overload issues and making prediction markets a real-time infrastructure across multiple industries.
CryptoCity1h ago
Prediction Market Kalshi Faces Class-Action Lawsuit Over Unpaid Winnings on Iran War-Related Contracts
Gate News Report, March 8, - Prediction market platform Kalshi was sued collectively. The platform failed to pay appropriate winnings to users of prediction event contracts related to the Iran war. Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour previously stated opposition to profiting from individual deaths and claimed he would refund fees for the "Will Khamenei step down" event contract market.
GateNews3h ago
Prediction market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket are both seeking funding at a $20 billion valuation
Gate News Report, March 8 — According to The Wall Street Journal, prediction market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket are in talks with potential investors for a new round of funding, with target valuations of approximately $20 billion each. Sources familiar with the matter revealed that both companies were valued at around $10 billion at the end of last year, and this funding round aims to double their valuation compared to late 2022. As competition in the prediction market intensifies, both sides are accelerating efforts to attract user growth and leverage this to drive negotiations for a new funding round.
GateNews4h ago
Polymarket Data: The probability of crude oil prices surpassing $100 in March skyrockets to 76%
Gate News Update, March 7 — According to data from the Polymarket website, the probability of the event "Crude oil prices will surpass $100 in March" has surged from a low of 35% yesterday to 76%, with trading volume exceeding $10 million. Previously, JPMorgan stated that even if the passage through the Strait of Hormuz is blocked for only 3-4 weeks, it could force Gulf Cooperation Council member countries to shut down oil production and push Brent crude oil prices above $100 per barrel.
GateNews03-07 00:31
Kalshi and Polymarket both aim for a valuation of $20 billion.
Gate News bot message: According to The Wall Street Journal, the valuation targets for prediction market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket are approximately $20 billion each.
GateNews03-06 22:42
