Apple removes Atmosphere programming app from the App Store, intensifying crackdown

Apple Removes Atmosphere Programming App From the App Store, Escalating Crackdown Efforts

Recently, Apple removed an atmosphere programming–type app from the App Store, saying it violated relevant regulations. This move clearly escalates enforcement against this category of apps.

According to Drewf・Amin, co-founder and CEO of the startup of the same name that developed the app, revealed that last Thursday, Apple removed the app Anything from the app store. Previously, The Information Journal reported that Apple had banned updates to multiple atmosphere programming apps—these apps use AI to let ordinary users without any programming experience develop applications—but allowed older versions to remain in the store. This time, Apple’s action came only a week after that report.

Atmosphere programming tools are an emerging software category, and they are driving a surge in new app releases on platforms such as iPhone. At the same time, however, these tools may also cause trouble for Apple: a large number of low-quality apps could flood the App Store. In addition, these tools may compete with Apple’s own developer tool Xcode, which has recently integrated Anthropic’s Claude and OpenAI’s Codex models to enable AI coding. Apple’s crackdown on this emerging app category could also prompt regulatory scrutiny, as regulators are closely watching new cases in which large tech platforms abuse their market-dominating positions to constitute unfair competition.

Although most apps generated through atmosphere programming tools tend to be fairly simple and have limited appeal, some more complex apps are expected to grow into sizable new businesses. Amin said that since Anything launched last year, users have published thousands of apps on the App Store using the tool, including emergency responder management systems and gig fee tracking tools.

“I think the potential of atmosphere programming is far bigger than Apple expected.” Amin said.

Apple did not respond to a request for comment regarding the removal of Anything. Previously, an Apple spokesperson said the company is not targeting atmosphere programming apps; it is simply enforcing existing guidelines: if an app makes a change to its core functions, it must submit to App Store review and may not make changes on its own. Apple’s concern is that AI-generated code may include functions that have not been reviewed and approved by Apple.

According to multiple related startups, Apple told the Anything team that the reason for the takedown was a violation of Section 2.5.2 of the App Store guidelines—this is also the same clause Apple previously cited when banning updates to other atmosphere programming apps. The guideline states that apps must “run as a complete, self-contained unit inside the app package,” and “may not read from or write data outside the specified container area, nor may they download, install, or execute code that would add to, change, or modify the functions of itself (or other apps).”

“A problem with Apple, or the entire closed ecosystem platform, is this: either they made a judgment error, or they simply decided that your app category is not allowed.” Amin said. If he cannot resolve the issue through negotiations with Apple, he is considering shifting the business to Google’s Android platform.

It is currently unclear why Apple chose to take down Anything at this time. Other atmosphere programming apps on the market can still be downloaded, including Replit and Bitrig, but Apple still prohibits updates to these apps (Replit’s last update was in January; Bitrig’s was in November). Amin said that other startups such as Vibecode have found alternative paths—stopping development of mobile iPhone apps and instead focusing on building pure web-based applications.

Also unclear is the specific reason Apple took action against Anything this time. Amin said Anything initially launched in August as an atmosphere programming app accessed through a browser. In November, the company released its first iPhone app, which successfully passed App Store review without any problems. Users can use Anything on the iPhone side directly to do atmosphere programming and preview the generated apps on the device.

Anything’s iPhone app had been updated successfully multiple times, but starting in mid-December, Apple’s app review team began rejecting the company’s update requests, citing violations of the 2.5.2 guideline.

After The Information Journal reported the incident earlier this month, Anything attempted to update the app so that users could preview the programming-generated app inside the browser rather than within the Anything app. Amin said Apple not only rejected that update request, but also removed the app entirely from the store.

A massive stream of information and precise analysis—exclusively on the Sina Finance APP

责任编辑：郭明煜