The "Ice and Fire" at the Negotiation Table and the Battlefield—Start of Islamabad Talks, Middle East Situation Still at a Crossroads

Early morning on April 11, local time, the Pakistani authorities confirmed that U.S.-Iran negotiations would be held that day at the Serena Hotel in Islamabad. Just hours before the negotiations began, Iran issued a final, tough statement—if an agreement acceptable to both Iran and the resistance forces is not reached, and fighting reignites, Iran will launch a "destructive strike" against Israeli and U.S. interests in the Middle East. Meanwhile, Israel's large-scale airstrikes on Lebanon have resulted in over 350 deaths, the Strait of Hormuz remains under strict control, and the Houthi forces have claimed to have attacked a U.S. aircraft carrier. Between the negotiation table and the battlefield, a game of "Ice and Fire" is simultaneously unfolding.
1. Islamabad: The Opening of U.S.-Iran Negotiations and the "Hard Battle"
Under the tight deployment of over 10k security personnel by Pakistan, the U.S.-Iran negotiations commenced at the Serena Hotel in Islamabad. The Iranian delegation was led by Speaker of Parliament Ali Larijani, including Foreign Minister Araghchi, Central Bank Governor Hemmati, and experts in security, politics, military, economy, and law. The U.S. delegation was led by Vice President Vance, including Presidential Envoy Wittkof and Jared Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law.
The statements made by both sides before the start of negotiations indicated this would be a "hard battle."
Iran’s position was firm. Supreme Leader Khamenei explicitly outlined "three points" in a written statement: aggressors must compensate for damages; management of the Strait of Hormuz will enter a new phase; Iran will never give up its legitimate rights and considers all "resistance fronts" in the region as a whole. Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister Ravanji confirmed that Iran would base negotiations on the previously proposed "Ten-Point Plan," including recognition of Iran’s control over the Strait of Hormuz and acceptance of Iran’s uranium enrichment activities. Foreign Minister Araghchi also emphasized that a ceasefire between Iran and the U.S. applies equally to Lebanon, and Israel must stop its military actions against Lebanon.
The U.S. also entered negotiations with a tough stance. Trump stated that if an agreement with Iran cannot be reached, the U.S. will intensify military actions, with the U.S. "re-deploying" and equipping warships with "the most advanced weapons." He further bluntly said Iran has "no cards left" besides controlling the Strait of Hormuz. Vance warned Iran not to try to "play tricks" on the U.S., but also said that if Iran is willing to negotiate "in good faith," the U.S. will remain open.
Regarding the format of the negotiations, it is still uncertain whether there will be direct face-to-face talks. Some reports suggest that the U.S. and Iran may first meet separately with Pakistan before deciding whether to proceed to direct negotiations. Trump predicted that the outcome of the negotiations would be clear within 24 hours.
2. Lebanon: Fire Unabated, Ceasefire Not Yet Achieved
Outside the Islamabad negotiation table, smoke still lingers over Lebanon.
Since Israel launched large-scale airstrikes on Lebanon, casualties have continued to rise. According to the latest statistics from the Lebanese Ministry of Health, the Israeli airstrikes on the 8th caused 357 deaths and 1,223 injuries. Since the resumption of hostilities between Lebanon and Israel on March 2, Israeli attacks have resulted in 1,953 deaths, 6,303 injuries, and over one million people displaced. On the eve of the negotiations, Israel launched an airstrike on the southern Lebanese city of Nabatiyeh, killing 13 security personnel.
It is noteworthy that both Iran and the U.S. still have serious disagreements over whether a ceasefire agreement should include Lebanon. Iran insists that a Lebanese ceasefire is a prerequisite for negotiations, with Larijani explicitly stating that the ceasefire in Lebanon and the unfreezing of Iranian assets must be completed "before negotiations begin."
Meanwhile, diplomatic channels are difficult to open. On the evening of the 10th, the Lebanese presidential palace issued a statement saying that the Lebanese and Israeli ambassadors to the U.S. had spoken by phone, and both sides agreed to hold their first meeting on April 14 at the U.S. State Department to discuss declaring a ceasefire and starting negotiations. Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu said he had instructed the government to engage in direct negotiations with Lebanon but also made it clear that "there will be no ceasefire" during the negotiations, and that the talks would not include a ceasefire with Hezbollah.
3. Strait of Hormuz: Strict Control, Limited Resumption of Navigation
After the U.S. and Iran announced a "two-week ceasefire," the situation in the Strait of Hormuz has not been as "reopening" as the U.S. claimed.
According to Iran’s reports on the 10th, only four ships passed through the Strait in the past 24 hours, including one Iranian oil tanker and one Russian oil tanker. The British maritime analysis firm Windward released a report indicating that the ceasefire has not led to a full recovery of commercial shipping, with standard channels in the strait largely unused. On the 8th, only five bulk carriers were tracked leaving port; on the 9th, activity increased but mainly involved small ships or vessels related to Iran.
More concerning is Iran’s clear statement that, in response to Israel’s violations of the ceasefire and attacks on Lebanon, the Strait of Hormuz has remained closed over the past two days. An Iranian Parliament National Security Committee member emphasized that current passage controls are extremely strict, and even non-hostile ships cannot pass by paying tolls.
Data shows that about 3,200 ships remain stranded west of the Strait of Hormuz, including roughly 800 oil tankers and cargo ships. Shipping companies are generally rerouting around the Cape of Good Hope, extending the usual route from about 25 days to approximately 41 days, with transportation costs increasing by about 25%.
The U.S. is trying to control the narrative. Trump claimed the Strait "will reopen very soon, no matter what." White House National Economic Council Director Harris stated that the strait could resume navigation within the next two months, and the U.S. has prepared "backup plans." However, analysts point out that April 8-10 was an initial testing window, and April 11-14 is the critical decision-making period for shipping companies—full recovery to pre-conflict levels may still take months.
4. Yemen’s Houthi Forces: New Threats Emerge
As the U.S.-Iran negotiations commence, the Houthis in Yemen issued a new warning.
On April 9, Houthi leader Abdul-Malik al-Houthi said in a televised speech that attacks by the U.S. and Israel are dividing the "resistance front," and the Houthis will not stand idly by. On the 11th, Houthi spokesperson Yahya Saree claimed that the organization had attacked the U.S. Navy aircraft carrier "Harry S. Truman" and its accompanying ships in the northern Red Sea using cruise missiles and drones in the past few hours.
This statement sends a very clear signal: if the U.S. and Israel continue to pressure Lebanon, the situation in the Red Sea and the Bab el-Mandeb Strait could escalate sharply. Previous Houthi attacks on ships have caused shipping costs in the Red Sea to soar. If the conflict spreads further, the global energy supply chain will face threats from both ends—the Strait of Hormuz and the Bab el-Mandeb Strait.
Meanwhile, British media reported on the 10th, citing informed officials, that the UK will hold a new round of talks with allies next week to discuss how to restore navigation through the Strait of Hormuz without paying Iran "tolls."
5. War’s Bill: Numbers Won’t Disappear with Ceasefire
No matter what agreement is reached at the Islamabad negotiation table, the costs of this war are irreversible.
WHO data shows that since February 28, the large-scale military strikes by the U.S. and Israel against Iran have caused nearly 2,400 deaths, over 32k injuries, and displaced 3.2 million people. Including nearly 2,000 deaths and over 1 million displaced in Lebanon, the conflict has resulted in over 4,000 deaths and more than 4.2 million displaced persons.
On the political front, U.S. consumer confidence index has plummeted to 47.6, a 10.7% drop from the previous month, reaching a historic low. The World Bank President warned that even if a U.S.-Iran ceasefire is maintained, the Middle East war will have chain reactions affecting the global economy.
6. Key Timelines: Future Uncertainties
The April 11 U.S.-Iran Islamabad talks—success or failure hinges on this—Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif bluntly said, "The success or failure of achieving a permanent ceasefire depends on this." Trump predicted that the outcome would be clear within 24 hours, but Iran insists, "Negotiations will only start if the U.S. accepts Iran’s preconditions."
The April 14 tripartite Lebanon-Israel-U.S. meeting—Lebanese and Israeli ambassadors to the U.S. will hold their first talks at the State Department to discuss declaring a ceasefire and starting negotiations.
Meanwhile, the UK will convene allies next week to discuss a "free navigation" plan for the Strait of Hormuz; threats from Houthi attacks persist; over 3,200 ships remain west of the strait— the future of the Middle East remains uncertain.
---
Conclusion: The Islamabad negotiation table has finally been set, but the gunfire outside the talks has never stopped. Rescue workers searching through Lebanese ruins, thousands of ships waiting on both sides of the Strait of Hormuz, and over four million displaced people in Iran and Lebanon—this game of "Ice and Fire" continues. The two-week ceasefire has entered its fourth day, but true peace in the Middle East—if it truly exists—may not be revealed within 24 hours. The only certainty is that every day’s delay continues to add to the already heavy war debt.
#Gate廣場四月發帖挑戰